Blog Pricing    Schedule    Class Descriptions    Instructors    Philosophy     Home    

The Tula View

Friday, August 26, 2011

Why I Won't do a Groupon

Often when I tell people that I am opening a new business, they ask if I will do a Groupon to up sales or to market it. I did think about it and I think there may be lots of advantages to doing one. First, it would be marketing, getting the name of the studio out there in a way that may otherwise be too expensive to do. Secondly, Groupons often bring a rush of people to the door. If you are lucky, you may be able to turn some of these deal-seekers into regular customers.

The more that I thought about it and the more that I heard about the experience from either customers of establishments that have run Groupons or from the business owners themselves, I find there are often more disadvantages to doing them than advantages. First, they literally take half your money (based on the discount price that you are already doing). So for example, if my monthly memberships are $129 and I wanted to run a Groupon for 50% off, then my offer would be $64.50 a month. Now if I told Groupon to take 500 of these, I would potentially make $32,500 - but once Groupon takes their cut - I would get $16,250. Now this may sound like alot, and it is, but if you take into account that without the Groupon running, if I was to land 500 members to the studio, I would get $64,500, the $16,250 doesn't sound so good! Now you could make the argument that I wouldn't be able to land 500 customers without the advertising reach of Groupon and you may be right, but in order to make the $16,500 that I would get from a Groupon, I would need to land only 125 customers! If I was to slowly earn the business of 125 people, I would not only grow my business, but I be more likely to gain 125 loyal, repeat customers and not just one time deal-seekers.

Many establishments that have run these Groupon deals, cannot handle the influx of people that come through their doors. I have heard many times that the companies' current customers are the ones that pay for this. The current customers are suddenly crowded out, often told that they need to make advance reservations to insure their spots to get serviced, etc. Regular customers often no longer get the quality of customer service they got before just because the company is trying to keep up with the Groupon-ers. This is a shame. I always thought that it was weird that companies tend to reward only new customers and not their current customers (the ones, by the way, that are keeping them in business). I understand wanting new customers, but I will never try to gain new customers at the expense or inconvenience of my regulars.

Now I know that the economy is tough and that everyone is looking for deals (myself included) and that's why I will give free class cards to those that are truly interested in checking out the studio, and to my instructors and my employees to give to friends and family. I will also regularly run specials and referral deals. I truly feel that the best way to not only earn customers, but to keep customers is through word of mouth and to connect with people outside of just a flashy advertisement. Now this may mean that I gain customers more slowly, but the customers that I gain will be the customers that I keep and that's all that matters.

10 comments:

  1. I think Groupon is a guaranteed and low effort marketing platform for businesses. Every new customer has a cost of acquisition. The smarter and more efficient your marketing efforts the lower that cost. Groupon can be the best thing in the world for new or existing businesses that do not have a marketing plan (shame on them). I am not endorsing Groupon, but it is easy to say, I am not going to do X.

    So my question is: What are you going to do instead?

    How can you get the name and philosophy of your new yoga studio in front of your target audience to get the monthly memberships sold without taking a 50% cost of acquisition hit?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey, you are right and when you look at this way, it doesn't make sense. Problem is that small businesses don't know how to market themselves. Groupon and mostly Groupon, not other daily deal sites, offer great way to promote your small business, however as with anything else, you need to know what you want and how to go about it.
    I know that they used to have so called Merchant Center which would let you create your own deals, they would take much smaller cut and you can control influx ie. you don't have to have 500 people right away, have 10 or 20 and then talk to them and see how they see you and what you can do to make things better before having another batch of them to check how you are doing now.
    After all it is your business and you should be responsible for your decisions, if you take daily Groupon and have 2000 people show up, you can't complain to Groupon for that, you were the one who agreed to it.
    Anyhow, I think your decision is wise one for now. It isn't easy making small business run, that will always be a challenge.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Agreed 100% with Rachel's comment above. Also, what makes you think Groupon would even accept you? Top tier deal sites (LivingSocial, Groupon) expect established or reputable businesses. You're too new and unproven to make the cut. You also sound naive in general.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Gotta love it. Unknown and Rachel: On Blogger since August 2011. Created a Blogger account just for Groupon/group deal damage control?

    ReplyDelete
  5. FYI, this post has generated some good discussion on Hacker News: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2931452

    ReplyDelete
  6. Groupon seems to take a lot for what they do. It seems like you could buy a good amount of local advertising for $16k.

    As a consumer, I've rarely discovered a new favorite place through a Groupon, I've pretty much always used it as a cheap night out. I don't think I'm alone, the chatter on the internet seems to indicate that businesses don't get a lot of new customers after running a Groupon. I've also had to stay away from a favorite restaurant for awhile because they ran a Groupon and started getting regularly sacked.

    Overall, I think you're being smart thinking in this way. Good luck on your business!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thank you for not doing a Groupon, Living Social, etc. Your promise is what just made me sign up for a monthly membership with Tula. One of the studios I went to ran such a deal. Before that, my practice was to buy a monthly unlimited pkg from them. Then the studio became so packed, I couldn't get in to to use it. When I did, the classes were uncomfortably crowded. And deciding to take a class at the last minute, not happening because classes were already full. What used to be a peaceful yoga practice turned into a weekly aggravation and waste of $.

    As a marketing manager for a local large business, I can say that we also declined to use these types of marketing deals. Even with a huge marketing budget, we found the results were short term and didn't give us a return on our investment. We got more long term business from referral rewards programs and VIP memberships. So, despite some of the comments above, please know that even large businesses have shared your astute opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Every marketing technique has its own advantages and disadvantages. We need to set up a plan carefully before engaging to any marketing strategy.
    excel 2010 training

    ReplyDelete